View Full Version : X-factor 08/11/08
Muppetgal
08-11-2008, 07:09pm
I'm off work tonight as my mum is here so we're going to watch it (despite the fact it's Mariah Carey night :zombie: )
So who is around watching tonight??
1980babe
08-11-2008, 07:12pm
Am waiting for it.
Mariah Carey week, hmm....
calgal
08-11-2008, 07:16pm
I'm watching :grin:
Was just about to start a thread :wink:
Gemiloch
08-11-2008, 07:19pm
mmmm not sure, I can't stick Mariah Carey but I'll give it a coule of songs and see if I'm pulling my hair out by then...
Muppetgal
08-11-2008, 07:19pm
I'm watching :grin:
Was just about to start a thread :wink:
ah, got in there before ya!! I used to do it last year when I didn't have a job that meant I had to watch it on rerun every week :sigh:. It's a novelty getting to watch it live!!!
:lol:
Ajedrez
08-11-2008, 07:23pm
Against my better judgement I have it on in the background - I can't BEAR MC though except for one song when she's on a rollercoaster in the video (god what an embarrassing admission!!)
Muppetgal
08-11-2008, 07:27pm
they don't usually have the guest star until the results show right??
calgal
08-11-2008, 07:27pm
I can't believe we are half way through the live shows :faint:
How gorgeous does Cheryl look every week??? And how high are her shoes this week :bow:
Bettie May
08-11-2008, 07:28pm
How is MC so successful.... I don't know anybody that likes her.... she is such an arse.
Bettie May
08-11-2008, 07:29pm
In love wit chew?????
Gemiloch
08-11-2008, 07:29pm
is her dress going to stay up til the end of the song????
Gemiloch
08-11-2008, 07:31pm
Ah I've just noticed the straps, I did wonder how exactly it was defying gravity so well :lol:
Ajedrez
08-11-2008, 07:32pm
she is such an arse.
She is!! A total arse.
I just went to rescue my bin from the wind in preference to hearing her caterwauling but returned to have my eyes pop out at her sprayed on dress - how on earth did it stay up??
Ajedrez
08-11-2008, 07:32pm
Ah I've just noticed the straps, I did wonder how exactly it was defying gravity so well :lol:
Ah good spot Gem!
Ajedrez
08-11-2008, 07:37pm
Someone should tell ee-og-han that the earrings are tragic.
Muppetgal
08-11-2008, 07:40pm
might have been an odd week for Eoghan (song choice wise) but actually I think it's the best he's ever sang!
Gemiloch
08-11-2008, 07:40pm
Someone should tell ee-og-han that the earrings are tragic.
:lol: combined with his scary helmet head hairdo I actually shudder a bit when I look at him!
Ajedrez
08-11-2008, 07:42pm
might have been an odd week for Eoghan (song choice wise) but actually I think it's the best he's ever sang!
We have different ear receptors - I heard blablabla bland YAWN.
Gem - he looks like an ewok in earrings.
Gemiloch
08-11-2008, 07:45pm
Gem - he looks like an ewok in earrings.
Headrest that actually made me snort my tea :lol: :bow:
I am captivated by this girls eyebrows though, they are astonishing!
Muppetgal
08-11-2008, 07:46pm
they seem to make Ruth's cleavage bigger every week!!!
And jeepers did she pick a HARD song, unfortunately too big for her, I think this will cost her votes.
Gemiloch
08-11-2008, 07:47pm
they seem to make Ruth's cleavage bigger every week!!!
it's to distract from her eyebrows I tell you!
Bettie May
08-11-2008, 07:47pm
Oof I thought Ruth was awful
Ajedrez
08-11-2008, 07:48pm
Ruth is 100% sexy - I was at my friends house this afternoon and her FIL was there and during an X Factor discussion (yeah I know, how sad:lol: ) he went "I like RUTH!" and I could practically see him rubbing his legs Vic Reeves style and drooling. She is definitely a man's woman! Twit twoo.
Didn't like her song though.
Gemiloch
08-11-2008, 07:49pm
She is hot, I have to agree with Cheryl (and headrest) :kiss2:
Song didn't really do anything for me though :shrug:
Rosebud
08-11-2008, 07:52pm
She is hot, I have to agree with Cheryl (and headrest) :kiss2:
Song didn't really do anything for me though :shrug:
I completely agree :nod: I find her very bland really
Gemiloch
08-11-2008, 07:56pm
What is with the frosted pink lipstick???
Me no understand!
Muppetgal
08-11-2008, 07:58pm
Shows how much I know of Mariah Carey, I have NO memory of her recording Endless Love!!
and here we go with THE SHOUTING FOR THE REST OF THE SONG!!! That is the one thing that really turns me off Laura.
Ajedrez
08-11-2008, 08:00pm
Shows how much I know of Mariah Carey, I have NO memory of her recording Endless Love!!
Me either:puzzled:
p.s. I am now on the wine so I shall probably be really cruel from hereonin so apologies in advance:twisted:
1980babe
08-11-2008, 08:00pm
Shows how much I know of Mariah Carey, I have NO memory of her recording Endless Love!!
She did it with Luther :wink:
donna-j
08-11-2008, 08:00pm
What have they dressed Laura in this week? They need to sort out her clothes.
ETA: Simon is always right :nod:
Muppetgal
08-11-2008, 08:05pm
argh, okay I know Mariah did this but come on it's a PHIL COLLINS song!!
and she's butchering it. OMG the whole thing is slightly out of tune!
Gemiloch
08-11-2008, 08:06pm
oh I don't like this song either :no: she's making my ears hurt :-(
Ajedrez
08-11-2008, 08:07pm
argh, okay I know Mariah did this but come on it's a PHIL COLLINS song!!
Exactly what I was going to say!
I am getting into this far more than I thought I would:lol: Rachel is MURDERING this song and it was already pretty dead in the water. :zombie:
Sparkly
08-11-2008, 08:08pm
Rachel sucks tonight. Actually the whole show is boring me tonight! :meh:
Muppetgal
08-11-2008, 08:08pm
well thank goodness that is over. My ears are sore now.
choccy eating monster
08-11-2008, 08:09pm
l like Ruth (the spanish one?). She is gorgeous and I could see all blokes liking her. I love her singing. I didn't like Rachel's singing tbh. I didn't like Ewock boy either, too bland, needs shorter hair.
donna-j
08-11-2008, 08:09pm
Yup, I thought it was dreadful.
Gemiloch
08-11-2008, 08:09pm
What's going on with Dannii's right nostril?? Does it always look like that? And is she deaf? A great performance?
Ajedrez
08-11-2008, 08:09pm
On a shallower note, I like Rachel's hair.
Franjay
08-11-2008, 08:10pm
Why are they being so nice to Rachel - she was awful!
Ajedrez
08-11-2008, 08:10pm
What's going on with Dannii's right nostril?? Does it always look like that?
Hmm it does look a bit tweaked.
Amaryllis
08-11-2008, 08:12pm
Watching it 5 mins behind (did a speedy bedtime!!) but OMG Rachel, SHOCKING!!
Muppetgal
08-11-2008, 08:19pm
hope this doesn't set a precident! Diana wouldn't have done well with a Mariah Carey song...wonder what she would have done??
Gemiloch
08-11-2008, 08:19pm
awww wee Diana, what a wee scone. I'm glad they're not letting her sing though, her voice sounded fecked in that vt.
Ajedrez
08-11-2008, 08:21pm
I don't think it's a big deal there's NO WAY she would have been binned tonight even if she'd been hanging upside down and screaming Metallica songs. She's in it for the long run - would have been a bit more suspect if it had been Daniel:lol:
Ajedrez
08-11-2008, 08:23pm
Oh for christ's sake, there must be some upbeat Mariah songs!!!
Does anyone else want to vomit with cringiness when the footage of JLS all putting their feet behind their legs comes on? CHEESE!
Muppetgal
08-11-2008, 08:24pm
ah I guess so, it will probably be Rachel to go home.
Apparently Chris Moyles on Radio 1 is rallying for everyone to vote for Daniel (probably as a joke I guess??) so I won't be surprised if he's not in the bottom two!
I'm loving JLS more and more every week. I would really really like them to win actually!
Ajedrez
08-11-2008, 08:26pm
Louis is a total bitch
(Girls Aloud wee all over Westlife!)
Gemiloch
08-11-2008, 08:27pm
I was making my dinner so didn' t see JLS.
I'm quite sure Cheryl doesn't have flu though, maybe a wee cold but if she actually had flu she'd be tucked up in her bed :rolleyes: (oooh I've lost my rolleyes cherry :grin:)
1980babe
08-11-2008, 08:27pm
Oh for christ's sake, there must be some upbeat Mariah songs!!!!
Couldnt agree more
Ajedrez
08-11-2008, 08:28pm
I was making my dinner so didn' t see JLS.
Feel lucky!:teehee:
Gemiloch
08-11-2008, 08:30pm
After your comments I do :nod:
durhamlass
08-11-2008, 08:31pm
I don't think it's a big deal there's NO WAY she would have been binned tonight even if she'd been hanging upside down and screaming Metallica songs.
PMSL
Muppetgal
08-11-2008, 08:31pm
RE JLS :
oh I so don't agree girls (and neither does my mum)
we both thought they were really good!
Poppopity
08-11-2008, 08:32pm
Daniel is so going to sing "without you"
Ajedrez
08-11-2008, 08:32pm
OOH Daniel now - should be interesting (or more to the point, not). I think it's really funny about the Chris Moyles thing! He's so not going tonight then!
Ajedrez
08-11-2008, 08:33pm
Daniel is so going to sing "without you"
Yep it was the words "key change" that gave it away!:lol:
Muppetgal
08-11-2008, 08:34pm
another friggin remake! This is Journey!
Gemiloch
08-11-2008, 08:35pm
I remember seeing his audition and thinking he was lovely but I'm not quite sure how he got into the live shows?
Ajedrez
08-11-2008, 08:36pm
Yawn I am pinning my hopes on Alexandra singing Heartbreaker to make me watching this worthwhile!!
Poppopity
08-11-2008, 08:36pm
Yep it was the words "key change" that gave it away!:lol:
I was thinking more that it goes along with his sob story.
Maybe not though :shock:
Rosebud
08-11-2008, 08:36pm
I find him a bit bleugh tbh :no:
Muppetgal
08-11-2008, 08:37pm
oooh, that was the most backhanded comment ever by Louis! :lol:
My mum said he is quite a pub singer, which is what Simon says about him most weeks!
Gemiloch
08-11-2008, 08:37pm
I didn't recognise that song either? In fact I've completely forgotten it already. Dullsville
Muppetgal
08-11-2008, 08:38pm
Open Arms by Journey, which is one of my all time favourite songs. It's from the 80's I think!
Ajedrez
08-11-2008, 08:40pm
Oh FFS - poke off Alexandra!!
Everyone listen to this instead:
http://uk.youtube.com/watch?v=4Mb3rdWUmbo
Much better!
Muppetgal
08-11-2008, 08:41pm
hahah Without YOU!!
seriously, does Mariah Carey ever do her OWN music. It's funny that on Mariah week they have mostly chosen songs that were remakes in the first place!
:lol:
Poppopity
08-11-2008, 08:42pm
Rachel sucks tonight. Actually the whole show is boring me tonight! :meh:
I can't stand Rachel, she's a vile chavvy attitude-ladden wannabe diva.
They're only keeping in her in the show becuase they're too scared of her outburst when she gets kicked out.
Ajedrez
08-11-2008, 08:42pm
Or even this:
http://uk.youtube.com/watch?v=e7iyjsLlsyk&feature=related
Gemiloch
08-11-2008, 08:43pm
Open Arms by Journey, which is one of my all time favourite songs. It's from the 80's I think!
Thanks MG :thumb:
sunshine
08-11-2008, 08:45pm
I have three words to say about this weeks show...
BARF IT MINGS!!!!!!!!!!!!!
What a pile of steaming shite.
Oh and stop gushing Alexandra, you are making me feel quite sick:pants:
Ajedrez
08-11-2008, 08:46pm
I have three words to say about this weeks show...
BARF IT MINGS!!!!!!!!!!!!!
:clap:
eta: but I have enjoyed assassinating them all on here!
Gemiloch
08-11-2008, 08:47pm
I have three words to say about this weeks show...
BARF IT MINGS!!!!!!!!!!!!!
What a pile of steaming shite.
Oh and stop gushing Alexandra, you are making me feel quite sick:pants:
:agree: :lol: :bow:
Poppopity
08-11-2008, 08:48pm
Oh and stop gushing Alexandra, you are making me feel quite sick:pants:
I agree ! WTF was that all about.
Chezza "Little Miss Showbiz" (:bow: Louis for that one) Cole is getting on my nerves as well. I'm not falling for her reinvention as the nation's sweetheart - she's a nasty piece of work.
Muppetgal
08-11-2008, 08:50pm
well that was a crap show!
Ruth and Rachel are my bottom two based on singing (even though I'm fond of Ruth)
Rachel to go! It was HORRIFIC!
OK, I just tried to rewind it to see what the judges said about (not sure of her name, the black girl who "sacked" Dannii - is it Rachel?) anyway, the girl who was SO fecking flat I could hear it when cooking dinner :yeahright: but Mr Minky had bloody changed the channel and I can't get back that far :hissyfit:
So what did they say? Can someone tell me pretty please?
Cos I thought she SUCKED and even Daniel was better than she was :nod:.
There are some singers with powerful voices there. But others, like Daniel and the boy group, are pretty average imho....
Minky x
calgal
08-11-2008, 08:55pm
I think Rachel & Ruth might be in the bottom two :scratchchin:
Really didn't enjoy this week :no:
That little guy in JLS really loves himself :yeahright:
How cute Eoghan has a little sister :lurve: , i was dying to hear her name but they didn't mention it, did they?
All the girls had their cleavage on show tonight!
*kate*
08-11-2008, 09:08pm
Utter crap tonight.
Rachel and :scratchchin: Ruth in the bottom two tonight. Or Rachel and Eoghan (but I think he'll get the sympathy vote for having a baby this week).
Franjay
08-11-2008, 09:15pm
Does anyone else think Mariah Carey looks weeeeird (she's on xtra factor right now)? Me thinks she has had a fair bit of work done.
Aurora
08-11-2008, 09:20pm
Boring week for me :rolleyes:
I missed Diana's performance so much :cry: - I hope she gets better for next week.
Alexandra was fantastic. She is growing on me week by week as I think her personality is great.
Eu-og-han was better than I expected this week. I enjoyed JLS's performance (I am glad that they didn't wear the red, green, yellow & blue tripe outfits.)
All the others were somewhere between ok and bad. Laura was just not up to scratch and Simon has a very valid point about her style, she is 21 years old FFS! What was she wearing tonight!
PLLLLLEEEEEESE someone tell me what the judges had to say!
I am on the edge of my seat! :laff:
Ajedrez
08-11-2008, 09:40pm
PLLLLLEEEEEESE someone tell me what the judges had to say!
I am on the edge of my seat! :laff:
I think they told her she was AMAZING (obviously lying like hairy eggs) and that she had an air of sadness about her. Simon said he liked her because he'd met her family and then she cried.
So no one mentioned all the notes she missed then? :shock: :loco: :rolleyes:
Thanks Aj!
Mariah careys face DOESNT MOVE. wrong so wrong
SaintSarah
08-11-2008, 09:51pm
I think they are too afraid to tell Rachel what they think of her, are they not? She was terrible this evening, totally flat - I really really hope she goes, although fear how she will react!!!
Aurora
08-11-2008, 09:53pm
I didn't notice her face not moving but I have to say I loved her gold dress :nod: It was so slimming and just looked wowzers.
Bit of a joke that the contestants were singing with her though....they weren't really were they?? They came out 10 secs before the end and they didn't even have microphones :teehee:
Totally agree with the above two posts. Mariah Carey has turned into a fembot :nod: and who knows what might happen if the judges told Rachel her vocal was rubbish?
:shock:
And was it just me and Mr M, or was Mariah only in second gear with that song - how disappointing was that! :nod:
lafleur
08-11-2008, 09:56pm
Did anyone pick up on when Simon was talking to Alexandra he said that he "really liked how she was enjoying the experience and never complained, and why would anyone complain when they're getting to do this?" Was it a sneaky little dig at one of the other contestants? If so, who?
Oh, and Rachel needs to go this week in my humble opinion! She's plop!
Chocolate Lips
08-11-2008, 10:00pm
Haven't read all the thread yet but when Mariah started singing Hero, OH piped up "she's got Diana's hand" :lol:
I thiught that lafleur- possibly rachel and her foul atttitude?? Although he seemed to be really arsekissig her this week :scratchchin:
RACHEL HAS BEEN VOTED IN
:faint:
Which just seems to prove to me the great British Public is tone deaf.
:yeahright:
SaintSarah
08-11-2008, 10:02pm
Oh my goodness, how is Laura in the bottom 2 and Rachel through :shock:
One Sock
08-11-2008, 10:02pm
RACHEL HAS BEEN VOTED IN
:faint:
Which just seems to prove to me the great British Public is tone deaf.
:yeahright:
My thoughts exactly.
Lovely as Daniel may be, how is he still in and Laura in the bottom two?
Chocolate Lips
08-11-2008, 10:04pm
Yep but didn't Lewpy go last year to the studios and though we had sat here saying "it was shite" she said it sounded wayyyyy different in the studio - so perhaps what we hear just isn't what it sounds like to them :shrug: It can be the only explanation in some cases :lol:
One Sock
08-11-2008, 10:05pm
Mariah careys face DOESNT MOVE. wrong so wrong
Quite terrifying isn't it?
I've been shouting 'make your face move' at the TV all night.
*kate*
08-11-2008, 10:09pm
Laura's in. That's fab.
Eh? Are you ahead of us oop north then Kate?
She's still singing dawn sarf. But much better than Ruth though, so I agree, she is in. Or she ought to be!
Minky x
SaintSarah
08-11-2008, 10:11pm
I really hope they save Laura
ticklepickle
08-11-2008, 10:13pm
Agree - I can't believe Daniel is still in - and Rachel too - but these two are in the bottom 2?! Travesty...
*kate*
08-11-2008, 10:14pm
Eh? Are you ahead of us oop north then Kate?
She's still singing dawn sarf. But much better than Ruth though, so I agree, she is in. Or she ought to be!
Minky xYeah I posted in the middle of the song, it was just my opinion :smile:
SaintSarah
08-11-2008, 10:14pm
:shock: I truly cant believe it
One Sock
08-11-2008, 10:15pm
This is mental.
Julesb
08-11-2008, 10:15pm
Freaking joke!
ticklepickle
08-11-2008, 10:16pm
OH MY GOD. Travesty. Makes a joke of these shows really that people like Daniel are still in. Gutted for Laura...
OOooh Cheryl isn't a very good loser is she :no:
OOooh Cheryl isn't a very good loser is she :no:
One Sock
08-11-2008, 10:18pm
OOooh Cheryl isn't a very good loser is she :no:
I don't blame her.
*kate*
08-11-2008, 10:19pm
What a shame :sad:
knotjustjigs
08-11-2008, 10:20pm
Absolute bloody madness .....I am in shock, Laura should not have gone! Daniel or Racheal imho
Ketty x
Woodstock
08-11-2008, 10:21pm
You know I was recording the results on sky+ to watch tomorrow morning and couldnt resist a sneak on this thread
and
OMG :no:
It was obviously done to make sure Cheryl doesnt dominate, but it shouldnt be about the judges. Makes the whole show pointless if Laura is out and people like Rachel and Daniel are in. Pointless.
Muppetgal
08-11-2008, 10:23pm
flabbergasted but only that Rachel is through, I knew Ruth's performance in the show wasn't up to scruff and truly felt Daniel did better than both RUth and Rachel.
I agree with Louis, Ruth has more "fight" in her...I'm surprised he didn't just go to deadlock though now.
I can see the headlines for tomorrow already.
Cheryl quits X-factor after snubbing by Louis!
lafleur
08-11-2008, 10:26pm
I don't know - Ruth may have more 'fight' in her, but since when was X-factor about finding the "fightiest" person? Laura is a better singer and has the potential to become a fairly credible recording artist, I think.
What a shame she went.
Chocolate Lips
08-11-2008, 10:26pm
I feel very sad, the wrong person went. I think if it had gone to deadlock Ruth would've gone as I'd bet she had the lowest public vote. I can't see her getting to the final.
But to be fair neither of them should have been in the final :shrug: I wonder if there's an element of the public not voting for the better singers/popular ones because they feel that they are safe.
ticklepickle
08-11-2008, 10:26pm
Louis is such a drama queen and so insincere, I can't bloody bear him. That's beside the point in view of tonight's result but even so... RAAAAAR!!!
Gemiloch
08-11-2008, 10:28pm
While I wasn't that keen on either Laura or Ruth tonight I thought they were both way better than Rachel! How the hell did she escape being in the bottom two? She was beyond shite :no:
Woodstock
08-11-2008, 10:31pm
There really should be voting like Big Brother where you vote for the worst person until the final show. That way you could make sure you get the worst singer off rather just hoping others agree with you in comparison to all the other singers.
But I guess they get more money this way (if you vote at all of course). :wink:
*kate*
08-11-2008, 10:42pm
Watching Xtra Factor now, and they've just shown a bit where the contestants went to a Bonfire and they were all cheering as the fireworks went off etc.
Diana was there, yelling like a good 'un. Maybe being out in the cold night air brought on her laryingitis? :yeahright:
Aurora
08-11-2008, 10:44pm
Diana was there, yelling like a good 'un. Maybe being out in the cold night air brought on her laryingitis? :yeahright:
I just thought the exact same thing...she didn't even have a scarf on so I bet her poor neck and throat got the chills. I wonder when she got poorly then :scratchchin:
Gemiloch
08-11-2008, 10:45pm
Great minds kate and Aurora! I was so about to post the same thing :nod:
I thought they said that she had been poorly all week but she was out and about and screeching her wee head of on Wednesday? If she already had laryngitis she should have been on complete voice rest :yeahright:
*kate*
08-11-2008, 10:46pm
I just thought the exact same thing...she didn't even have a scarf on so I bet her poor neck and throat got the chills. I wonder when she got poorly then :scratchchin:Or when she got cold feet........I've gone off Diana a bit now.
Miss Frosty
08-11-2008, 10:47pm
I missed it tonight but am I right in thinking that Laura went out :shock:
flipflop
08-11-2008, 10:49pm
Just caught up on it all on V+.
OMG, how could Laura have gone :faint: , she was one of the best singers, just as Austin was (imo!).
Louis is a weasel - he's only got JLS so is clearly voting off any proper opposition, I bet he's hoping for a JLS/Daniel final :lol:.
I :lurve: Alexandra, she's fabby. Disappointed that Diana didn't sing tonight, otherwise I thought they were all very average, apart from Rachel who was awful. She is quite terrifyingly aggessive.
judygg
08-11-2008, 11:17pm
OMG she was totally robbed - you could see Cheryl was genuinely shocked, reckon she thought when it got to the last three that hers would be safe cos Daniel was the most likely to have gone.
It really annoys me that she has gone when others like Daniel or Rachel have gone through but lets face it won't win it anyway. What a waste.
Helski
08-11-2008, 11:18pm
Am really gutted that Laura went. I LOVED her.
Thought the sing off was great from both girls, such a shame they were in the bottom 2 but poor Ruth doesn't have a hometown campaigning for her does she so I guess will never do great in the public vote.
Rachel was shoite tonight.
Daniel is good cabaret at best.
Eoghan is growing on me.
I HATED Mariah Carey night tho - bit of a yawn fest for me. Hoping for a better choice next week.
CutieMcpretty
09-11-2008, 12:16am
Simon Cowell has really annoyed me how can he be a talent mogul and save RUTH....is the man deaf???
Louis is a dope and doing my head in.
I agree Daniel should of been there with Ruth.
I am so shocked its not funny, gonna watch the xtra factor in the morning to see what the judges have to say...
Diana, another drama...
Mariah Carey is she wooden?
lazybones
09-11-2008, 03:18am
omg why the hell did laura go??
ive not seen the full night but wtf:faint:
lazybones
09-11-2008, 03:18am
omg why the hell did laura go??
ive not seen the full night but wtf:faint:
Muppetgal
09-11-2008, 08:06am
I don't know - Ruth may have more 'fight' in her, but since when was X-factor about finding the "fightiest" person? Laura is a better singer and has the potential to become a fairly credible recording artist, I think.
What a shame she went.
I disagree, I think Ruth is the better singer. Laura has a strange voice and I wouldn't buy her records.
Ajedrez
09-11-2008, 08:58am
I've just come on to find out who got binned and I am flabbergasted - Laura!? What a joke. But, I do think that she will be fine, someone will snap her up.
The judging seems to be based on the whims of the judges i.e. "oh lets get rid of Laura so that Cheryl doesn't get too big for her boots".
I thought Ruth was rubbish last night although she did look amazing but it's not a beauty contest.
tigger71
09-11-2008, 09:13am
Am late to this thread.....just don't get me started on the result!!!!!!!!!!:hissyfit: Way to go guys, get rid of one of the finalists who can actually sing! Can't wait to see what they do next week.
Bet Daniel wins now......:grin:
xx
Annie Goolahey
09-11-2008, 09:24am
I don't think the voting is to keep Cheryl in her place.
I think it was simply tactics from Simon and Louis who know they would be fecked if either of their acts was in a sing off with Laura.
It was a wise decision from the side of the judges backing their own acts but a travesty for the idea it is a fair and real talent show.
(That said, and I know he's local) but I really did feel Eoghan did well last night.)
Lovebug
09-11-2008, 09:37am
I don't think Ruth and Laura should have been in the bottom 2 but out of their songs that they did to stay in comp Ruth was miles better , laura has such an individual voice that it does not lend itself well to many songs and I think sometimes when she sings she sounds strained when trying to reach ceratin notes also I think she looks like a perma tanned man in drag most of the time.
Woodstock
09-11-2008, 11:29am
Bet Daniel wins now......:grin:
xx
The way its going I wouldnt be at all surprised :loco:
Flora Poste
09-11-2008, 12:54pm
Just watched this on sky+ and I 'm so shocked. Who the hell is voting for Daniel and Rachael - they were both godawful tonight - especially Rachael.
And Ruth should so have gone in the sing off.
Elle Driver
09-11-2008, 12:56pm
I agree Flora. I'm absolutely disgusted that Laura went and that Daniel stayed in (wasn't even in the bottom two, i mean). Shocking :no:
I agree with you too Annie, the Louis and Simon booted off Laura as she would be too strong a competition in later shows, should it come to sing offs etc.
I feel like boycotting it now :lol: :loco: I am honestly GUTTED Laura went :cry:
Elle Driver
09-11-2008, 01:01pm
I've just come on to find out who got binned and I am flabbergasted - Laura!? What a joke. But, I do think that she will be fine, someone will snap her up.
This is what I've been trying to console myself with :lol: :oops: I want her to get a recording deal. I would love to buy her albums! :-(
'Line - I dont think Cheryl Cole was a bad loser as such. She didn't rant or rave - she just looked totally gobsmacked and I bet she felt complete disbelief at the unjustness of Laura going. I know I was sat there like this >>>>>>>>>>> :shock: :cry: :no: :shock: when the judges made their decisions.
I'll say it again - I am disgusted!!!!
One Sock
09-11-2008, 01:27pm
I am honestly GUTTED Laura went :cry:
Me too. Am a bit :oops: to admit it was one of the first things I thought about when I woke up this morning
Note to self - must get a life.
Aurora
09-11-2008, 03:14pm
I am just reading The News of the World online :oops: and Paul McNamara has written an article on last nights show with his take on all the acts.
I know it is a little :meh: but I totally agree with what he said on Daniel.
Why even bother singing? He should just come out to a disappointed audience, look straight into the camera and shout, ‘MY WIFE’S DEAD’.
I am still gutted that Laura has gone.
Katiekipper
09-11-2008, 04:01pm
The whole 'keeping Daniel in and making him an internet pet charity case' is getting incredibly BORING. Someone as amazing as Laura leaving really brings it home.
I thought Ruth sang worse so assumed that Louis is particular booted off Laura to give JLS a better chance. Simon probably kept Ruth in so he could have a better chance at pulling her (if he's not already done so)
I hope Laura leaving causes a backlash against voting for Daniel tbh.
ChelseaHarvey
12-11-2008, 10:34am
I watched this lastnight & was another one that wa shocked that those 2 were the bottom 2. Def not right & Daniel should have def been one of those in the bottom 2.
How fab was Mirah though & wow look at her now she is so tiny as well. I love her, & she has such a fab voice, Loving her new song out as well, 1 def for the old ipod
Powered by vBulletin® Version 4.2.0 Copyright © 2013 vBulletin Solutions, Inc. All rights reserved.